Two people have told me this week that #3 is really good at singing. One was the music teacher at the school, who ought to know a good singer when she hears one. “She keeps very good pitch,” she said. Can this be the same girl we’re talking about? I wondered. #3 Likes to make up tunes, and I guess her talents do not extend to the creation of music, at this point in time anyway.
The headmistress, on the other hand, said that she had missed #3 on Wednesday (when she was off school ill) and hoped she would come back because she is basically the lead singer and it all fell apart dreadfully without her. #3 has great confidence, at least in a group, and will sing nice and loudly where others mostly just mumble along. Without her, I suppose the group just mumbled, while with her they would probably all sing a bit louder just because of the competition, if nothing else.
So I find myself wondering if this is her “thing”. I do hope so. We can build on it, if that is the case. She needs something, I know that. I was telling her about all these people saying how good she was, and how proud that made me feel for her, and she put her hands over her ears and asked me to stop saying nice things to her. “It makes me feel strange,” she said. “I don’t like it.”
I asked her if it made her feel uncomfortable. If she felt she didn’t deserve it. If she thought she only deserved to be shouted at and told off. She agreed with all of these. Which is really, really sad. No 6-year-old should feel that they don’t deserve praise. What have we done to her?
She is a difficult child, quite hyper, never listens, very clumsy, never thinks about consequences in any way shape or form. So she does get told off a lot. And shouted at because just asking quietly simply never gets through. And I always feel bad about it, but it seems the only way most of the time. But now it is definitely time for a change, because I cannot face myself about this, about the way she’s feeling. I have told her Dad too. We have to stop saying things like “You never…..” and “Why is it always you?” and “You always…..” Always and Never are about to become banned words in our house, except in those very strict circumstances where they are absolutely correct, necessary or are being used positively (eg “You are always so good at getting in the bath.”)
I know this smacks of modern, liberal, wishy-washy “positive parenting”, but at the minute my daughter’s self-esteem is being crushed and it seems as though we are the ones responsible for that. It is a hard time for the middle 2 children at the minute. They know their sister is moving out soon, but there is no real fixed date for anything at present. #2 in particular can’t really cope with such open-ended arrangements, and I think it’s getting to #3 too. So they need support through it, and a lot more patience than they have been getting from us. I think things will settle down after the summer, but in the meantime I must try much harder.
Anyway, I am just about to go and hear this singing angel at her final assembly, and if she really is as fantastic as they say, I will have to see what can be done to give her a boost, something of her own that she’s really good at, and that can bolster her overall confidence. Talented? I think there is a strong possibility that she is.